
MEP Design in Heritage Buildings: 8 Lessons from Our Recent Projects
At SCC we've worked on some fantastic heritage buildings across Northern Ireland and Ireland over the years. Pulling together a tender bid this week made me think about just how much our team has to consider when designing for listed buildings and heritage projects.
MEP design in a heritage setting often comes down to what we choose not to do – protecting existing fabric that has stood for centuries. But "less is more" doesn't mean these projects are easier to design. Fees can be significantly higher on heritage projects, because of the time needed to understand the existing fabric and work through the unknowns that appear once we're on site.
To help with my bid, I asked the team about challenges they've overcome on recent and ongoing projects. They came back with some great insights.
1. Start with what's already there
A proper survey of the existing services is crucial and shapes every decision that follows. In so many historic buildings we survey, you can see that services have been patched and extended over the years, and some services are left in situ but have sat unused for a long time.
Recently, we completed St Patricks Tower in Dublin which is a 1757 smelt mill that had been stood unused for years. The general power and lighting circuits were well past their serviceable life. Rather than trying to salvage anything, leading to future problems, we had to strip back everything to source and install new distribution boards and circuits up to current Irish Standards.
Knowing early on that a clean slate was needed allowed us to carefully plan out new routes, see what old routes could be salvaged and rule out old routes that were no longer suitable.
2. Every penetration counts
Thick stone walls and original floor slabs are not forgiving. The first questions we ask are: how few openings can we get away with, where are they allowed, and can existing routes do the work?
At St Patrick's Tower, we reduced the electrical routes to a single rising point, using an existing core in the wall from the switch room to the floors above. Ductwork through the Level 1 slab was cut down during design to just two ducts serving the event space. The structural engineer reviewed every penetration, and we relocated or removed any that would have put the slab at risk.
At Ardee Castle, a standard letterbox opening for containment would have meant new concrete or steel lintels above doors and openings. Instead, we redesigned the containment route to use small individual cores, avoiding the need for new structural heads.
At Customs House, we reused existing risers and plant spaces wherever we could, in line with HED requirements. Working within these spaces often meant designing to millimetre accuracy.
3. Ventilation without the damage
Meeting current Building Regulations and CIBSE guidance in an old building is one of the hardest challenges in heritage work. Ducts, fans and grilles can easily spoil the very features a project sets out to protect.
At Ardee Castle, we needed to ventilate the building without harming the courtroom panelling and ornate ceiling details. Our answer was to use different ventilation strategies in different spaces. Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) went into the exhibition space, which had fewer restrictions and a new suspended ceiling to hide the ductwork. In the courtroom and café, we proposed natural ventilation through actuated opening windows – designing out ductwork, fans and grilles altogether.
Sometimes a building doesn't need one system; it needs several, each suited to the requirements and restrictions of the space.
4. Lighting that celebrates the building
Great lighting can show off the historic features visitors and building users should notice. The challenge is fixing and feeding the lighting without cutting into walls and ceilings.
At Ardee Castle, in-ground uplighters highlight the stonework of the front façade – wall-mounted fittings would have meant coring through heavy, protected walls. Inside, suspended pendants, ring fittings and suspended linear track lighting will light up key features while keeping builder's work minimal and limiting work on listed ceilings.
At St Patrick's Tower, suspended track lighting with adjustable spotlights and colour temperature control lets the space adapt to each exhibition or event. Outside, uplighters illuminate the tower itself and the new paved seating area.
5. Protecting the fabric itself
Engineering in a listed building is about services that look after the building and protect its heritage.
At St Patrick's Tower, we provided electric background heating to storage and circulation areas. This helps control humidity and reduces the risk of condensation forming on the stone walls. After weatherproofing works on Level 2, we added a leak detection tape system on Level 1. It protects the new space below and raises an alarm at the security desk in the neighbouring building, so any water ingress is caught before it causes damage.
6. Energy efficiency within heritage limits
Clients rightly want low-carbon buildings, but many of the usual options are off the table in a listed building. The challenge is finding savings that don't change how the building looks.
At Customs House, a listed building by Sir Charles Lanyon, solar PV was ruled out because of its historic status. Instead, we specified a VRF heat pump system that moves heat from rooms with too much to rooms that need it. A thermal wheel in the air handling unit recovers heat from exhaust air, and a building-wide BMS monitors and controls heating, cooling, ventilation, power and water. LED lighting with automatic controls cuts energy use in shared spaces.
Plant space was so tight it was designed to within 100mm of clearance. That level of precision is often what makes efficient systems possible in a building that was never designed for them.
7. Spot problems early and design them out
On heritage projects, a small oversight can turn into a big cost. The earlier a problem is found, the more options the design team has to solve it without touching the building.
At Ardee Castle, there was no room for risers. Modifications to the castle itself were heavily restricted, so a new extension was proposed to the rear. Early conversations with the architect meant the new risers could be located in the extension to serve the building. Left unchecked, this could have stalled the project, limited how the building was serviced, or led to long discussions with heritage bodies and costly redesign. By front-loading the design and fitting the services into the extension, the castle needed few or no extra penetrations. We also selected equipment specifically for tight spaces, without compromising maintenance access.
Early on at St Patrick's Tower, we realised the MVHR unit wouldn't fit up the stairs. The only route to the upper floors was a shallow timber staircase, and the contractor couldn't get the unit up it. The alternatives were costly: crane the unit in through the windows (meaning removing them), or strip out the historic staircase and build a new one just for the installation. Doing nothing would have left the space without proper ventilation – bad for occupants, and bad for old stone walls prone to condensation.
Instead, we reviewed how the space would be used with the client and agreed a lower occupancy. That allowed us to reduce the airflow rate and specify a physically smaller unit that fitted through the existing stair opening. The staircase and windows were untouched, and the client avoided extra cost and delay.
8. It takes a whole team
No engineer can get a heritage project right alone. The best outcomes come from early coordination – the design team around the table and meeting on site.
At St Patrick's Tower, the conservation architect reviewed the acoustic ceiling panels against our services locations to produce a fully coordinated ceiling plan. An acoustic consultant advised on ceiling baffles, which we built into the MEP design, and the structural engineer checked every penetration against the existing slabs. Together, the team coordinated reflected ceiling plans and layouts so the services supported the flexible way the event space would be used.
At Customs House, the client wanted a WELL Platinum rating. We worked with the WELL Assessor from the very first workshops to agree which credits were realistic in a historic building, including higher ventilation rates, advanced lighting controls and strict glare limits.
Final thoughts
Historic buildings were never designed for modern heating, ventilation, power or data. Our job as engineers is to bring them up to standard while leaving the smallest possible footprint. That means surveying carefully, questioning every penetration, choosing the right system for each space, and raising risks before they become problems.










